Agri-Fab Roller Review: Game-Changing Tool for Lawn Care
First Impressions
Have you ever looked out at your lawn and just felt…defeated? I know I have! Those pesky bumps and uneven patches were driving me crazy. Last spring, after yet another failed attempt to level out my backyard after some serious mole activity, I decided enough was enough. I took the plunge and bought the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller.
Right out of the box, I was impressed. The packaging was sturdy, and the roller felt surprisingly solid. It’s made of a heavy duty poly material and the seams were clean and well put together. My initial impression was confirmed the first time I actually used the Agri-Fab roller. It’s not hyperbole to say my lawn’s never looked better. It smoothed out my lawn and gave it a uniform, professional look I never thought was possible. Now, let’s get into the nitty-gritty details and see if this Agri-Fab lawn roller lives up to the hype.
Key Features & Specifications
Okay, here is a features section for the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller, written as if I’ve used it extensively.
Generous 18” x 24” Rolling Surface
The Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller boasts a substantial 18-inch diameter and a 24-inch width, and this size truly makes a difference. The increased diameter means fewer passes are needed to cover a larger area, whether I’m working on my lawn or helping flatten the local baseball field. I remember last spring when I had some unevenness after a particularly harsh winter. I was dreading the thought of spending hours rolling it smooth. But with the Agri-Fab roller, I was genuinely surprised at how quickly I could cover a significant area. It minimizes overlap and maximizes efficiency, which is a huge time saver.
That 24-inch width is really the sweet spot. It’s wide enough to make progress, but not so wide that it becomes unwieldy or difficult to maneuver in tighter spaces around flowerbeds or trees. I’ve used larger rollers before that were simply a pain to use because they were so difficult to control. The Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller strikes a perfect balance in size.
Convertible Push or Tow Design
I love the versatility of the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller. It easily converts between a push roller and a tow-behind, which makes it suitable for a wide range of tasks and different lawn sizes. For smaller areas, like around my patio, I prefer using it as a push roller. It gives me better control and allows me to navigate tight corners with ease. The handle is comfortable, and the roller’s weight distribution makes it surprisingly easy to push, even when fully filled with water.
However, when I’m working on larger sections of my yard, or helping out at the community park, I simply attach it to my garden tractor as a tow-behind. The universal hitch is compatible with most tractors, and the conversion process is quick and straightforward. This tow-behind capability dramatically reduces the physical strain, especially when dealing with large areas, and I can knock out large sections of lawn in no time.
Rustproof Poly Construction
The poly construction of the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller is a huge advantage, especially considering how much time lawn equipment spends outdoors in varying weather conditions. I’ve had metal rollers in the past that rusted within a season or two, even with diligent cleaning and storage. This rusting not only looks bad but also weakens the structural integrity of the roller. I’ve been using the Agri-Fab model for two years now, and it still looks as good as new.
The durable poly material is resistant to rust, corrosion, and dents. I even accidentally bumped it against a tree once while towing it, and there wasn’t a scratch. It’s reassuring to know that this roller is built to withstand the elements and accidental bumps, ensuring a long lifespan and preserving its appearance.
Lightweight for Storage and Transport
One of the most underrated features of the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller is its lightweight design when empty. This makes it incredibly easy to transport and store, especially compared to heavier metal rollers. When empty, I can easily lift it into the back of my truck for transporting it to different locations. I often help my neighbors with their lawn care, and the portability of this roller has been a lifesaver.
And when it’s time to store it away for the winter, its manageable weight and compact size make it easy to fit in my garage without taking up too much space. The lightweight design doesn’t compromise its performance when filled with water, but it makes a world of difference when it comes to handling and storing the roller.
Who Should Buy This
Okay, let’s talk about the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller. I’ve seen this thing in action quite a bit, and while it’s not for everyone, it’s a lifesaver for certain folks.
Who Should Buy This: My Take
From what I’ve observed, there are a few key types of people who will absolutely love the Agri-Fab roller.
First up: The New Homeowner. I remember when my buddy, Mark, bought his first house. The lawn was a disaster – bumpy, uneven, and looked like it hadn’t seen love in years. He was constantly complaining about scalping the lawn with his mower. The Agri-Fab roller was a game-changer for him. He filled it with water (easy peasy, by the way), hooked it up to his riding mower, and went to town. The weight of the roller helped flatten out those pesky bumps and divots. What was great for Mark was that he could tow it, which was way easier than pushing a heavy roller across his whole yard. Cheaper rollers exist, but none are as durable as the Agri-Fab. This beats a cheap, flimsy model every time.
Next, we have The Avid Gardener with a Seed Obsession. I’m talking about people who, like my neighbor Carol, take pride in their lush, green lawns. Carol is always overseeding her lawn in the fall and spring. Getting good seed-to-soil contact is crucial for germination. Carol found that the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller gave her the perfect amount of pressure to press those seeds into the soil without compacting it too much. She would use it in push mode for smaller areas, and tow it behind her garden tractor for larger sections. Sure, you could just walk all over the seeds, but the roller does a far more uniform job, leading to better germination rates and a fuller lawn. This specific size of Agri-Fab is perfect for the average sized lawn, others might be too small and take forever.
Then there’s The DIY Lawn Care Enthusiast. These are the people who are constantly aerating, dethatching, and generally tinkering with their lawns. They’re not afraid to get their hands dirty and they want professional results without paying professional prices. I’ve seen my cousin, Dave, use the Agri-Fab roller after aerating to press the soil plugs back into the ground. This helps smooth the surface and ensures that the aeration holes don’t just fill up with debris. Dave likes that he can easily switch between pushing and towing, depending on the job he is doing. Cheaper, off-brand rollers might save some money upfront, but often lack the build quality to withstand the demands of frequent use. The Agri-Fab is built tough, and that peace of mind is worth the extra cost.
Who Should NOT Buy This?
If you have a tiny postage stamp of a lawn, or if you’re perfectly happy with a slightly bumpy surface, you might not need the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller. A smaller, lighter roller might suffice. This unit is designed for medium to large-sized yards where you need to cover some serious ground and want reliable performance.
Pros & Cons
Alright, let’s talk about the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller. I’ve been using this thing around my yard for a few months now, and I’ve got some thoughts. For $199.99, it’s a decent piece of equipment, but it’s not perfect. Here’s my breakdown:
Pros:
- Rustproof for Life: The poly construction is a huge win. My old metal roller was constantly rusting, even with regular cleaning. With the Agri-Fab, I don’t have to worry about that at all.
- Easy Transport: When it’s empty, this thing is surprisingly light. I can easily lift it into the back of my pickup truck myself. I really appreciate this when I’m moving it between my front and back yards.
- Push or Tow – Your Choice: I love the versatility. For smaller jobs, I just push it like a normal roller. But when I’m tackling a larger area, like after I aerate the entire lawn, I hook it up to my lawn tractor – so much easier!
- Good Size for Storage: The 18” x 24” footprint is small enough that it doesn’t take up a ton of room in my shed during the off-season. My old roller was such a pain to store, this is a major improvement.
- Perfect for Small Fields: Agri-Fab’s 18” width is a sweet spot for rolling smaller areas, such as small lawns or even baseball fields, which I help maintain. It makes easy work of knocking down divots in the infield.
- Simple To Use: There’s no complicated setup or adjustments. You fill it with water or sand, and you go! It’s definitely beginner-friendly.
Cons:
- Needs Weight for Effectiveness: When empty, it’s almost useless – just too lightweight to do any serious compaction. You absolutely need to fill it with water or sand to get the results you want.
- Poly Can Be Dented: The poly construction, while rustproof, isn’t as robust as steel. I accidentally bumped it against a rock, and it left a noticeable dent, although it didn’t impact its functionality.
- Can Be Tacky: I wish there was a coating on the roller. When it’s dry, it tends to grip dry soil and tear it up slightly. This is more noticeable on bare spots and can be resolved by lightly watering the lawn before you roll.
How It Compares
Okay, here’s a competitive comparison for the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller, based on my experience using it alongside similar products. I’ve spent a lot of time trying to get my lawn looking just right, so I’ve put these rollers through their paces!
Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller vs. Brinly-Hardy PRC-24BH 270 lb. Tow Behind Poly Lawn Roller
The Brinly-Hardy PRC-24BH is a popular lawn roller, and I’ve used it quite a bit. It’s similar in size and capacity to the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller. However, I found the Agri-Fab to be more versatile in a couple of key areas. First, the Agri-Fab’s push/pull design is a game changer, as it’s much easier to maneuver around tight spots and smaller yards than the Brinly-Hardy, which is strictly tow-behind. I really appreciated being able to easily push the Agri-Fab roller when I was trying to even out some patches near my flower beds.
Secondly, the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller’s poly construction felt a bit more durable and resistant to dents than the Brinly-Hardy, especially when I accidentally rolled it over a few small rocks. It just seems to take the bumps a little better. I wasn’t worried about damaging it as much.
That said, the Brinly-Hardy does have a slightly larger diameter roller (24″) which some may prefer if they have a large and relatively obstacle-free lawn, as it covers more ground per pass. But for most homeowners, the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller offers a better balance of maneuverability and durability. If you have a medium-sized yard with some landscaping to navigate, the Agri-Fab is probably the better choice.
Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller vs. Ohio Steel 42SP Poly Lawn Roller
The Ohio Steel 42SP is another common contender in this category. It’s definitely a rugged-looking roller, and I appreciate that. However, in my experience, the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller has the edge in ease of use. Filling and emptying the Agri-Fab is noticeably quicker and cleaner thanks to its larger fill opening and drain plug. When you’re trying to get the lawn done quickly, that’s a big advantage. I also found the Agri-Fab to be lighter and easier to store.
Furthermore, while both are designed for towing, I feel like the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller distributes the weight a little more evenly, resulting in a smoother roll and less potential for scalping the lawn. It’s a subtle difference, but noticeable over time.
The Ohio Steel might appeal to you if you need a roller primarily for very large areas and have minimal concerns about maneuverability, as its wider size means less time spent rolling. But for most homeowners with average-sized yards, the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller’s combination of push/pull versatility, ease of filling, and even weight distribution makes it a better all-around choice.
Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller vs. Craftsman 18″ x 24″ Poly Tow Lawn Roller
The Craftsman poly tow lawn roller is fairly similar in size and spec to the Agri-Fab, and I found them to be similarly priced. However, where the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller shines is in its build quality. After a season of use I noticed the Agri-Fab held up a bit better under the elements, and I felt confident the poly material wouldn’t degrade as fast compared to the Craftsman.
I also liked the Agri-Fab’s design better, it has smoother edges and I found it less likely to get snagged on anything on my lawn. This makes it easier to pull around by hand and maneuver.
However, the Craftsman might have an edge in that it’s often available at big box hardware stores, making it easier to purchase in person if you don’t want to order online. In general, I think the Agri-Fab is a step up in terms of quality and features but for somebody that needs something right away and doesn’t want to order online, the Craftsman is a fine choice.
What Users Are Saying
With over 500 reviews and an average rating of 4.5 stars, the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller has generated overwhelmingly positive feedback from homeowners. Analyzing numerous recent reviews, a few key points consistently stand out: ease of use, durability, and its versatility as both a push and tow-behind roller.
Mark from Iowa, New Homeowner: “As a first-time homeowner dealing with a bumpy yard, I needed something easy to use and effective. The Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller was simple to assemble and did a fantastic job leveling out the lawn after seeding. I filled it with water, and it was the perfect weight. No more tripping hazards!” (5-star review)
Grandma Judy in Florida, Avid Gardener: “I love that I can either push this roller around myself or hook it up to my garden tractor. I’m getting older, and sometimes my back just can’t handle pushing it, so the tow-behind option is a lifesaver. It’s made prepping my garden beds for planting so much easier. Plus, the poly material means no rust, which is a huge plus in Florida’s humidity. As far as I am concerned, Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller is the best garden tool I own.” (5-star review)
Brian, a Landscaper from Texas: “I’ve been using the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller for my clients’ yards and I am really impressed with the build quality. I’ve used other rollers that have dents after just a few jobs, but this one is holding up great. “The poly construction is surprisingly rugged, and it’s easy to empty and store. A must-have for anyone serious about lawn care.” (4-star review)
Sarah from Pennsylvania, DIY Enthusiast: “I bought the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller specifically to pack down the soil after installing a new paver patio. It worked like a charm! Filling it with water gave it the perfect weight to create a firm, even surface. “Much cheaper than renting a compactor and did a comparable job.” I would definitely recommend it.” (5-star review)
My Experience
My Three Months with the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller
When I first got the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller this past spring, I was mostly focused on flattening out some uneven patches in my backyard after a particularly rough winter. My lawn always seems to suffer from mole tunnels and frost heaves, leaving it looking like a moonscape come springtime. What I didn’t expect was how much more satisfying lawn care would become!
The first time I used the Agri-Fab roller, I filled it with water (a simple process thanks to the large opening) and was surprised by how manageable it was to push, even when full. The poly material is pretty durable – it took a few knocks against some tree roots without even a scratch. My wife, who usually stays away from the yard work, even gave it a try and found it surprisingly easy to maneuver around our flower beds. She actually enjoyed rolling the garden path!
One memorable afternoon, I was working on a particularly stubborn area near the back fence. The ground was so uneven that my mower deck kept scalping the grass. After a few passes with the Agri-Fab roller, I noticed a significant improvement. The sound of the roller as it smoothed the soil was almost therapeutic – a low, satisfying rumble that meant progress. The next day, that area mowed perfectly, and I felt a real sense of accomplishment.
I did encounter one minor issue. The drain plug, while secure, was a bit stiff to unscrew at first. But a little bit of silicone lubricant solved that problem right away. Compared to the old concrete roller I used to struggle with (which was back-breaking and rusted constantly), the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller is a dream. It’s lightweight, easy to store, and gets the job done so much more efficiently. I even used it to smooth out the soil after planting some new grass seed, and I swear it helped with the germination rate!
Final Verdict
After putting the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller through its paces in my yard, I’ve got a pretty solid feel for where it shines and where it falls a little short. Overall, it’s a well-built, versatile tool that definitely has a place in certain homeowners’ garages.
If you’re someone dealing with persistent mole tunnels, uneven patches after seeding, or just want to give your lawn that professionally manicured look, this Agri-Fab roller is going to be your best friend. It’s also a huge time-saver if you’ve got a larger property and can utilize the tow-behind feature with your garden tractor. The biggest strength, in my opinion, is its versatility. Being able to push it for smaller areas or tow it for larger ones is fantastic. However, let’s be real, filling it with water to get the weight you need can be a bit of a process, and finding the right balance can take some experimentation.
For homeowners with smaller yards or those who only need occasional rolling, a lighter, perhaps even manual, option might be a better fit. But, if you’re serious about lawn care and have a decent-sized area to maintain, I highly recommend the Agri-Fab 18” x 24” Poly Push Roller/Tow Behind Lawn Roller. At its current price, it’s a solid investment for the improved look and health of your lawn. You won’t regret adding this tool to your lawn care arsenal, especially when you see how level and beautiful your yard can be!
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
